Home / Fraud protection / Overpayment quiz

Refund & overpayment scam red-flags quiz

Eight short situations small shops actually see. Pick the safest next step, then read why. This quiz stays in your browser and does not score you on a server.

Question 1

A new customer pays $1,800 for a $600 order and asks you to refund the extra $1,200 by wire, gift cards, or a payment app. What should you do first?

Question 2

You receive a screenshot or “payment confirmation” email that looks official, but the money is not in your merchant account or bank. The buyer wants the goods today.

Question 3

Someone claiming to be a previous customer emails from a slightly different address and says they overpaid last month. They want a refund sent to a new bank account or a friend.

Question 4

A buyer pays with a check or an ACH transfer for more than the invoice and asks you to “just send the rest to my mover / supplier / assistant.”

Question 5

A “payments officer” writes from a lookalike domain of your processor or bank, saying your account was over-credited and you must return funds immediately to keep the account open.

Question 6

A customer asks you to refund a return as store credit, then immediately asks you to “cash out” that credit to a different card, app, or person because their card was “lost.”

Question 7

Which of these is the safest general rule for unexpected extra money?

Question 8

You already shipped an order. The buyer now says they accidentally paid twice and wants one payment sent to a “logistics partner” who will also collect the package if needed.